ShipMyCar US
Buying & SellingNovember 17, 2026·7 min read

Autotrader vs. CarGurus: Which Is Better for Buying a Car (and Shipping It Home)?

Quick Answer

Autotrader vs CarGurus compared: pricing tools, search filters, dealer and private listings, and buying out of state. Plus how to ship your car home.

Last updated: November 17, 2026

Cars parked in front of building during daytime
Photo by Felix on Unsplash

Autotrader and CarGurus are two of the biggest places to shop for a used car online. Both are free to browse, both list cars from dealers and private sellers, and both let you search well beyond your own city. They differ in how they help you judge a price and how they present listings.

This comparison covers what each site does well, when to use which, and what to do once you've found the right car in another state.

Free car shipping quote

What will it cost to ship your car?

Get Your Free Quote

Free quote in 60 seconds · We never sell your info

1
Route
2
Vehicle
3
Contact
Open Transport
Most popular
Enclosed
Max protection

Free · No credit card · Takes about 60 seconds

Autotrader vs. CarGurus at a Glance

Here's a quick side-by-side of the features most buyers care about.

Feature: Owner
Autotrader
Cox Automotive (also owns Kelley Blue Book)
CarGurus
CarGurus, Inc.
Feature: Pricing guidance
Autotrader
Kelley Blue Book price ranges on many listings
CarGurus
Instant Market Value and a deal rating on each listing
Feature: Listing types
Autotrader
Dealer and private seller
CarGurus
Dealer and private seller
Feature: Price history
Autotrader
Shown on some listings
CarGurus
Price history and days on market
Feature: Dealer reviews
Autotrader
Yes
CarGurus
Yes
Feature: Selling your car
Autotrader
Private listings and instant offers
CarGurus
Private listings and instant offers
Feature: Cost to browse
Autotrader
Free
CarGurus
Free

What Autotrader Does Well

Autotrader has been around since the 1990s and is part of Cox Automotive, the same company behind Kelley Blue Book and the Manheim auctions. That connection shows up in its pricing tools: many listings show where the price falls compared with Kelley Blue Book values.

Strengths:

  • Detailed search filters for features, packages and colors
  • Kelley Blue Book pricing context on many listings
  • A large mix of new, used and certified pre-owned inventory
  • Research content and reviews to help narrow choices

Watch out for: Sponsored and featured listings can appear near the top of results. Sort by price or distance to see everything.

What CarGurus Does Well

CarGurus built its reputation on price transparency. Every listing gets an Instant Market Value estimate and a deal rating — Great, Good, Fair, High or Overpriced — so you can see quickly how a price compares with similar cars.

Strengths:

  • Deal ratings that make bargains easy to spot
  • Price history and days on market on listings
  • Dealer reviews and ratings
  • Easy nationwide search radius

Watch out for: A deal rating looks only at price and listed features. It can't tell you about damage, wear or a car that needs work, so a "Great Deal" still needs an inspection.

Want your actual price? Request a free quote in 60 seconds — no payment, no spam.

Get My Free Quote →

Which Should You Use?

Use CarGurus when price is your main concern and you want to find below-market cars fast.

Use Autotrader when you're narrowing down specific features, trims or packages, or want Kelley Blue Book pricing context.

Use both. Many dealers list on both sites, but not all, and private sellers often pick one. Searching both gives you more inventory and lets you compare how each site rates the same car. Once you've found a car, the steps to buy and ship it are the same.

Buying Out of State From Either Site

Both sites make it easy to find a better deal far from home. Before you commit:

  • Run a vehicle history report using the VIN, and check NICB's free VINCheck for theft or total-loss records.
  • Get an independent inspection near the seller. See mobile mechanic pre-purchase inspections.
  • Confirm the title is in the seller's name and find out whether there's a loan on the car.
  • Pay through a traceable method and verify payment details directly with the dealer.
  • Ask about out-of-state paperwork, including temporary tags and who handles sales tax.

Our step-by-step guide to buying and shipping a car from CarGurus applies to Autotrader purchases too.

MacBook Pro on white table
Photo by QingYu on Unsplash

Shipping Your Car Home

Once the sale is final, book a licensed auto transport company. Typical open-carrier prices for a standard sedan:

Distance: Under 500 miles
Open Carrier
$400–$750
Distance: 500–1,000 miles
Open Carrier
$700–$1,050
Distance: 1,000–1,500 miles
Open Carrier
$950–$1,300
Distance: 1,500–2,000 miles
Open Carrier
$1,100–$1,500
Distance: 2,000+ miles
Open Carrier
$1,300–$1,800

Shipping Tips for Online Buyers

  • Make sure the car is paid for and released before the carrier arrives. Tell the seller the carrier's name and pickup window.
  • Ask the seller to be present at pickup or to take photos alongside the driver.
  • Inspect at delivery and note any new damage on the Bill of Lading before you sign.
  • Compare dealer delivery offers with a direct shipping quote. Some dealers offer delivery, and it's worth checking whether their price is fair.

Is the deal still worth it after shipping? See shipping a car vs. buying locally.

Want your actual price? Request a free quote in 60 seconds — no payment, no spam.

Get My Free Quote →

Selling on Autotrader or CarGurus

Both sites let private sellers list a car and offer instant cash offers from dealers or partners. A private listing usually brings a higher price, while an instant offer is faster. If you sell to a buyer in another state, get paid in full before the car leaves. See how to ship a car you just sold.

Search Tips That Work on Both Sites

  • Widen your radius. Set the search to several hundred miles or nationwide. The best deals are often in a nearby state.
  • Save searches and turn on alerts. Good prices go fast; alerts tell you when a matching car is listed or a price drops.
  • Sort by newest listings. Fresh listings at good prices sell quickly.
  • Check the same car on both sites. Many dealers list everywhere, and the descriptions or photos may differ.
  • Read the full listing. Look for one-owner history, service records and the number of keys included.
  • Call before you travel or ship. Confirm the car is still available and that the price matches the listing.

A little patience pays off. Prices on both sites change often, and a car that's been listed for a few weeks may have more room to negotiate than a brand-new listing.

Private Sellers vs. Dealers on Either Site

Dealers handle title paperwork, temporary tags and often out-of-state sales tax, and some offer warranties. Prices may include dealer fees, so ask for an out-the-door price in writing.

Private sellers often ask less, but you handle more of the paperwork and payment safety yourself. Confirm the title is in the seller's name, check for a loan, and use a safe payment method. Private sellers are also less likely to have experience with shipping, so explain how the pickup will work.

Either way, an independent inspection is the best protection when you can't see the car yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Autotrader or CarGurus better?: Neither is better for everyone. CarGurus makes it easier to spot below-market prices; Autotrader is strong for detailed feature searches and Kelley Blue Book pricing context. Many buyers use both.

Are Autotrader and CarGurus free?: Yes, both are free to browse and contact sellers.

Who owns Autotrader?: Cox Automotive, which also owns Kelley Blue Book.

Can I trust a CarGurus Great Deal?: It means the price is below CarGurus' estimate for similar cars. It doesn't confirm the car's condition, so get a history report and inspection.

Can I buy from another state on these sites?: Yes. Verify the car and seller, pay safely, and ship the car with a licensed transport company.

How much does it cost to ship a car I bought online?: About $400–$750 under 500 miles, up to $1,300–$1,800 coast to coast on an open carrier.

Do Autotrader and CarGurus have the same cars?: Many dealers list on both, but not all. Private sellers often choose one, so searching both gives you more options.

Source: every broker and carrier's operating authority, safety rating, and insurance status is public record — verify any company for free at the FMCSA SAFER System.

Ready to Ship Your Car?

Get your free, no-obligation quote in 60 seconds. Guaranteed pricing with no surprises.

No upfront paymentNo commitment to quoteLicensed & insured carriers4.9/5 rated service